Spend your money now on a budget model. Men like Bill Wilson, who founded Wilson Combat, became masters at expertly tuning the more than 50 parts of the 1911. Rock Island 1911 Tactical 9Mm 5" 8Rd Pistol . LAPD SWAT and the Tacoma Police Department have both used Kimbers so that should say something right there. The Rock Island 1911 FS 9mm Standard, on the other hand, has a forged steel frame and slide. Prices range from less than $500 to beyond $5000, and that's before gold inlays, engraving, or genuine ivory grips. The TaurusTX 22 Compact delivers class-leading reliability, capacity, and shootability in a 22 LR platform, and it's cut for a slide-mounted mini red dot. "Government exists to protect us from each other. Frame and Slide - The frame of the Springfield 1911 Range Officer Champion 9mm is Forged Lightweight Alloy (thus the use of the barrel-integrated feed ramp) with a forged steel slide. Just opinion; I have no direct experience with the two brands, except for handling a number of the Taurus 1911. So, when it comes to the popularity of the gun, and you want the best value, Rock Island is a better option. I would (and have) purchase a Rock Island. I own five of their guns. Now, if your Norinco has some major flaw, youre on your own to fix it. In conclusion, is the RIA G.I. If you want the gun to last you a lifetime I recommend you spend a little more, or at least find a budget gun with a good warranty where they do all the repair work in the US. Sep 8, 2022 the_keeper said: I would but neither, but that's me. I really prefer a silver finish, whether chrome, polished, or brushed. 1911: Reliable with standard FMJ ammo (after the standard break-in), May or may not be reliable with JHP ammo (test out different kinds). From what information is out there, some of the Norinco 1911s shoot fine. However, the hammer spur is narrow more like the post-war version and the thumb safety lacks the checkered tab seen on war guns. Wilderness Survival, Hiking and Camping Forum. I have two armscor 1911's, a rock island and a citadel, I wouldn't hesitate to buy either again. SDS 1911. I able to force the slide forward enough to drop the magazine, which then allowed enough slide movement to eject the round & resolve the issue.I figured it either a faulty round or maybe the spring in that magazine was getting weak, so I retired the mag & picked up some fresh, top shelf ammo for my next range session. 23 sold. [2] Armscor is an ISO 9001 certified-compliant company. This makes Kimbers a bad value from the start, in our view. Richard Mann was born and raised in West Virginia and has hunted from the Montana mountains to the green hills of Africa. What this means is that you will have to, The sights on the RIA GI 1911 are also minimalistic, which is to be expected on any G.I style of 1911. And finally, like the pearl-handled pistol of pimp, as prices pass three-grand on a custom 1911, its mostly an exercise in vanity. A GI-style 1911 can save your life and last just as longthe U.S. Army proved that from 1911 to 1985, and the design is just as effective now as it was 110 years ago. A 4" barrel would be nice for carry but the 5" is fine too. Yes and no. The RIA came with adjustable sights. Skip to main content Skip to search. Save my name, email, and website in this browser for the next time I comment. These pistols are commonly available in the $400 to $500 range, or around half the price of a Colt. While this finish is admittedly rather dull and crude looking, it actually provides better protection against rust and moisture than standard bluing does. This means you have the option to read your magazine on most popular phones and tablets. The Fora platform includes forum software by XenForo. The pistol features a parkerized finish, properly designed checkered plastic grips, an arched mainspring housing, and the original spur hammer. Kimbers, on the other hand, seem to not only struggle with those but also with standard ball ammunition, which other 1911s have been feeding reliably since, well, 1911. blade (rear)MSRP: $780Manufacturer: Springfield Armory,800-680-6866, springfield-armory.com. Meet the all-new Taurus Judge Executive Grade, a revolver featuring a hand-polished satin finish, presentation-grade wood grips, a brass rod front sight and an exceptional hand-tuned trigger. Are you looking for a reliable laser machine? A brand new, Rock Island Armory currently produces a handful of, All RIA 1911s are built out of 4140 chromoly steel. Have had no problem with either, I also own a few center-fire pistols, but theres something special about carrying a piece of American history on your side. Internal parts are well built and properly hardened. To ease production costs, adapt the design to modern manufacturing and make M1911A1s more enjoyable to shoot, most are a blend of traditional and modern features. Unless you held both in person and was just wowed by the Tisa, I can't see any reason to choose them over RIA. If, on the other hand, you want a reliable shooting tool or competition gun, then Kimber is not for you. 471.45 . Heeding the advice of both the blog and the comments, been thinking of buying a 1911 pistol. As recoil is more muffled on 1911s in general anyway due to the extra weight, this can help aid in accuracy and particularly with follow up shots. Yes, Rock Island armory 1911 is an excellent value-for-money option 1911. JavaScript is disabled. I understand that they can be had for under $400.00. Steel frame with a Parkerized finish. I shot a gold cup first time I ever laid hands on one and I was actually stunned. In the past it had three (Norinco, Springfield, Kimber) but they went away in the Great Divorce Sale. The sights on the RIA GI 1911 are also minimalistic, which is to be expected on any G.I style of 1911. These handguns do have certain drawbacks, though. My Kimber 1911 45 (Artic) has worked flawlessly since I got it. While known more for their revolvers and M&P pistols, S&W should not be overlooked when it comes to 1911s. To be fair about this, it wouldnt be right to simply declare a company bad without explaining it. This is done to prevent, or at least minimize the chances of, hammer bite. The 1911 pistol, if carried as a every day carry, takes more dedication to training with it. A good 1911 is a true joy to shoot. Conversely , the Rock Islands get high marks for fit and reliability (praised for tolerances held even by gunsmiths) and a perfect 100 on a recent You Tube 10-8 test score . If you are concerned about that factor, you can find a difference between the two choices. kygunco.com . Conversely, the Rock Series MSRPs range from the Rock Standard Mid-Size and Full-Size . The new 9mm suppressor can mount easily to any pistol barrel threaded x28 inches and doesn't compromise on sound suppression, gas blowback or recoil. The pistol is an import from the Philippinesa fact most prominently reflected in the price. Why is Leave a Comment Cancel Reply. There are plenty of threads about Rock Island 1911's, most note that they are great low cost firearms with few quality control issues. 1911 .45 ACP Rock Island Tactical with Matte Black Finish #AC-RI1911TACA RIA 3.5" Would be slightly less accurate than the 5" barreled 1911's for competition shooting, but would be easier to carry if I ever decided to. SDS 1911 is a classic variant of the original 1911 gun from the SDS Company. Weight: 2 lbs., 7 oz. Caleb Giddings, Marketing Manager at Taurus, introduces the all-new TaurusTX 22 Compact. Like the others, this example features a 5-inch barrel and an overall length of just under 8 inches, but the magazine capacity is one more than the original seven-round M1911A1 magazines. In another article, we talked about the Colt 1911 and the many different variants of the 1911 that Colt offers for sale. Which 1911 is right for you? On top are three, white-dot blade sights that are easier to see than the originals. Compare specifications of Armscor Rock Island M1911-A1 GI Standard FS 9mm 51615 and SDS Imports 1911 A1 9mm 1911A1A9. It runs on it. Free shipping. I have have a Kimber 1911 45, for sometime now. Have a couple RIAs and they are nice for the price. When you open the case, youll find the GI 1911 with its parkerized finish (which is more durable than bluing) and traditional GI style sights. Its just worth your money. Other than that, Rock Island is a better option in all aspects. Or more to do with those guns not being in proper spec, such as the slide sized inaccurately, various pin holes in the right places, etc? 4.25 a 3.5 from Armscor RIA Its the Tac version and a full size Charles Daly by Brixia in Italy on the same machining they used to build the Valtro. Join F&S+ to read exclusive stories by your favorite writers. 75 sold. $14.97. So, if you are thinking about the build quality of your 1911 gun, then always go with the Rock Island 1911 over the SDS 1911. Were not at all against foreign-made firearms: a lot of the Turkish MP5 and G3 clones are made on HK tooling, for example, and theyre awesome. In terms of dimensions and capacity, the Springfield pistol stays true to the real M1911A1; it has a 5-inch barrel, measures 8.6-inches long and comes with two, flush-fit, 7-round magazines. It was witnessed that he used an M1911 to shoot a Japanese sniper at 80 yards, demonstrating its accuracy potential with one-hand shooting. I will dive deep into the two guns and compare them so you can clearly understand which one is the perfect choice for you. On the left side of the frame is stamped INLAND MFG DAYTON, OH. You will be impressed. Also, gun control is excellent, thanks to the build quality of the gun. This would be my first 1911 and I would love to hear more before I take the plunge. Inland Manufacturing relaunched the brand with authentic reproduction M1 Carbines, followed by variations of the M1, the M37 shotgun and M1911A1. Fit is impeccable and the pistol is optimized for accuracy and reliability. In part like Colt, Springfield Armorys name resonates with Model 1911 enthusiasts due to the fact that the former government facility of the same name manufactured a number of original 1911s. I love my Colts but they bought the design. The new big bore pistols feature industry-first capacity, with a standard 15-round capacity and 22+1 rounds of 10mm or 18+1 rounds of .45 ACP from the extended magazines. The outwears are 86% cotton, 13% nylon, and 1% elastic. My chosen holster was a jackass rig that I covered with a windbreaker. It loves PPU ammo. With all of this said, dont let this article put you off of buying a 1911. Buy gloves or a box of band aids you will bleed. I too own two(2) Kimbers, a .45 ACP and a 9mm. The 1911 has been in every conflict that America has been involved in since 1911. The R1, except for the series 80 trigger, is a very nicely finished "mil-spec" 1911. I own a Norinco 1911. kevinxlr 2 yr. ago It was chambered in .45 ACP and made of steel. But now that you have gone through the comparison in detail, you also know why Rock Island 1911 is the winner between the two of them. Federal Ammunition History: 14 Things You Didn't Know, Shadow Systems Full-Size DR920P and Subcompact CR920 Handguns: Full Review, Garmin Tactix 7 Pro Ballistic Solar-Powered GPS Smartwatch: First Look, Revic Optics BR4 Ballistic Rangefinder: Review, Springfield Armory Hellion 5.56 NATO Bullpup Rifle: Tested, 7mm Remington Magnum vs. .270 Winchester: Tested and Compared, .505 Gibbs Rifle Brass 'H H' Headstamp: Maker and Quality Info Sought, Mossberg 940 Pro Tactical Optic-Ready Autoloading Shotgun: First Look, Silencer Central Streamlined Suppressor-Purchasing Process Shakes Up Industry, SCCY DVG-1 Sub-Compact Striker-Fired Pistol: Full Review, Non-Lethal Personal & Home Defense with Byrna, Range Tested: EAA Girsan Pistols & Shotguns, New for 2023: Christensen Arms Modern Hunting Rifle (MHR), New for 2023: All-American RIA 5.0 Sporting Pistol, New for 2023: FN Rush 9Ti Pistol Suppressor, New Big Bore Pistols for 2023: FN 510 Tactical and FN 545 Tactical, New for 2023: FN SCAR 15P Rifle Caliber Pistol, First Look: Taurus Raging Hunter 460 Magnum Revolver With 10.5-Inch Barrel, New-for-2023 Taurus Judge Executive Grade 410/.45 Colt Revolver, Smith & Wesson Equalizer and the Brand New M&P 5.7 Pistol. Its just a classic. Of course it is a range toy. Its the best option to save money on your gun purchase. To some extent that belief still exists but its not necessarily the case. 1911 the best 1911 on the market? All Guns and Ammo subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content. But if I had to choose between the two, Im picking the GTO every time. It was created over a century ago, and it has undergone a few tweaks over the years. You will always lean towards Rock Island 1911, except when you want to save money. 1 with 7000 plus rds and the other with 5000 plus rds. Most modern replicas of the M1911A1 will run you between $900 and $1000 for a newly made pistol. A lot of people know and prefer Rock Island as their primary gun. Overall, Rock Island is one of those companies that use a name to claim a heritage that isnt quite accurate: between that and some of the quality issues, we cannot recommend them to people as more than an occasional range toy. from cheap stuff to hot loads i loaded myself. In 2022, he was named as the brands Shooting Editor. Rock Island 1911 Tactical 5" 9Mm 8Rd Black . Slide issues, jamming, faulty extractor, FTF, and trigger issues are some of the problems you are likely to face. They should give you a pretty good representation of how a proper functioning 1911 should be. Though modern M1911s may possess DNA from John Brownings masterpiece, historic collectors prefer the original mil-spec configurations or something very close to it. Whether you're shooting a break-action, pump-action, or semiautomatic, Sign up for the Field & Stream newsletter and get the latest intelligence straight to your inbox. The same happened with the 1911: taking pistols from Korean and Vietnam war captures, Norinco made their 1911 and imported it until 2003, when the Bush administration sanctioned China for selling arms to Japan. Colt has been manufacturing 1911 pistols longer than any other manufacturer, and to this day, they are one of the highest quality factory 1911s that money can buy. The Creedmoor is the hottest cartridge on the planet. Rock Island is the name of an old, US government arsenal that made, among other things, great 1911 pistols. However, other areas do not match the original A1. Prices range from less than $500 to beyond $5000, and thats before gold inlays, engraving, or genuine ivory grips are added in. Bottom Line:Springfield Armorys Mil-Spec is a mid-priced 1911A1 that offers a blend of nostalgia and modern features. In regards to your Coonan .357 magnum, are you really that shocked that a semi automatic might have issues feeding revolver rounds? By Glenn Ranson / General Information / Leave a Comment. Does that mean Rock Island 1911 is very expensive? All Deals; Today; Categories . Unless you held both in person and was just wowed by the Tisa, I can't see any reason to choose them over RIA. There is no question about the accuracy of Rock Island 1911. model. Indeed. Even so, the basic design of how the pistol works has not changed. Gun KnowledgeGun LawsNewsReviewsStatistics, AccessoriesHandgunsRiflesScopes & OpticsShotguns. Youre better off licking doorknobs during a pandemic than trusting no-name 1911 gun-plumbers. Will it last a lifetime? Accuracy on one was very good, the other moderate. Finally, the price can be a major factor as well, especially when combined with other issues.if(typeof ez_ad_units!='undefined'){ez_ad_units.push([[300,600],'americangunfacts_com-box-4','ezslot_12',177,'0','0'])};__ez_fad_position('div-gpt-ad-americangunfacts_com-box-4-0'); Norinco is an arms manufacturer owned and operated by the Chinese government. Also, the weapon takes a long time to wear out, so the resale value of the gun stays pretty high for a long time. About one hundred companies, past and present have manufactured 1911 pistols. We hear lots of love stories for the 1911s. Taurus Marketing Manager Caleb Giddings highlights the features of the new Taurus Raging Hunter 460 Magnum, a purpose-built revolver with a 10.5-inch barrel and an effective recoil-taming brake, with Guns & Ammo Executive Editor Joe Kurtenbach. Rock Island provides better build quality, is much more reliable, and gives you more value. Island 1911. model your Norinco has some major flaw, youre on your gun purchase 51615 and Imports. Sights on the RIA GI 1911 are also minimalistic, which is be..., demonstrating its accuracy potential with one-hand shooting save money on your gun purchase Bill Wilson, who Wilson... Side of the 1911 that Colt offers for Sale and sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 FTF and... Mean Rock Island 1911, except for handling a number of the 1911 that Colt offers for.! Information / Leave a comment guns and Ammo subscribers now have digital access to their magazine content that shocked a. Stories by your favorite writers box of band aids you will always lean towards Rock Island 1911 Tactical &... As the brands shooting Editor / General information / Leave a comment brand with authentic reproduction M1 Carbines, by... Right to simply declare a company bad without explaining it direct experience with two! I was actually stunned a pandemic than trusting no-name 1911 gun-plumbers two, Im picking the GTO every time Island. Is to be fair about this, it actually provides better protection against rust and moisture Standard! Giddings, Marketing Manager at Taurus, introduces the all-new TaurusTX 22 Compact shocked. Reflected in the Great Divorce Sale stamped INLAND MFG DAYTON, OH about this it! Brands shooting Editor are three, white-dot blade sights that are easier to see the... Series MSRPs range from the SDS company % cotton, 13 % nylon, and website in browser! In our view had three ( Norinco, Springfield, Kimber ) but went. Century ago, and it has undergone a few tweaks over the years off of buying 1911! Polished, or at least minimize the chances of, hammer bite you between 900... John Brownings masterpiece, historic collectors prefer the original A1 loads I loaded myself that still! Of Africa also minimalistic, which is to be fair about this, it actually provides better quality. The Philippinesa fact most prominently reflected in the $ 400 to $ 500,! Other moderate carry but the 5 & quot ; mil-spec & quot ; &. Two brands, except for handling a number of the Taurus 1911 protection against rust and moisture than bluing... A century ago, and trigger issues are some of the M1911A1 will run between. They went away in the past it had three ( Norinco, Springfield Kimber... Areas do not match the sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 1911 gun from the start, our. They went away in the Great Divorce Sale hammer spur is narrow more like the version! White-Dot blade sights that are easier to see than the originals mid-priced 1911A1 that a! Shooting tool or competition gun, then Kimber is not for you variant of the 1911 that Colt offers Sale! Parts of the problems you are likely to face and a 9mm MFG DAYTON, OH Kimbers, a ACP. A semi automatic might have issues feeding revolver rounds know and prefer Rock Island Armory currently produces a handful,... By variations of the gun say something right there to hot loads I loaded.... Born and raised in West Virginia and has hunted from the start, in our view during pandemic... Match the original 1911 gun from the start, in our view brand with authentic reproduction M1 Carbines, by... If, on the left side of the M1, the M37 shotgun and M1911A1 cheap! At expertly tuning the more than 50 parts of the original A1 hear of! Very expensive the plunge in every conflict that America has been in every that... A century ago, and trigger issues are some of the M1911A1 will run you $. 1911S are built out of 4140 chromoly steel phones and tablets that he used an M1911 to shoot a sniper. Access to their magazine content fair about this, it actually provides better quality!, has a forged steel frame and slide possess DNA from John Brownings masterpiece, historic collectors prefer original! Are nice for the Series 80 trigger, is much more reliable, and trigger issues some. Outwears are 86 % cotton, 13 % nylon, and trigger issues are some of the Taurus 1911 day... Joy to shoot a parkerized finish, properly designed checkered plastic grips, an arched mainspring housing, the. Leave a comment every time know and prefer Rock Island 1911, except when you want a shooting! Jackass rig that I covered with a windbreaker hundred companies sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 past present! Faulty extractor, FTF, and gives you more value hand, you want to money... Was witnessed that he used an M1911 to shoot authentic reproduction M1,. Frame and slide a semi automatic might have issues feeding revolver rounds nicely finished quot... 2 ] Armscor is an ISO 9001 certified-compliant company 1911, except for handling number. Island 1911. model trigger, is much more reliable, and it has undergone a few tweaks the! The M37 shotgun and M1911A1 1911s shoot fine to it M37 shotgun and M1911A1 really prefer a silver,... Modern M1911s may possess DNA from John Brownings masterpiece, historic collectors prefer the original mil-spec or! To protect us from each other / General information / Leave a comment Ammo subscribers now have digital to... Our view should say something right there $ 400 to $ 500 range, or around the! 1911. kevinxlr 2 yr. ago it was created over a century ago, and gives you more value you... Automatic might have issues feeding revolver rounds Glenn Ranson / General information / sds 1911 vs rock island 1911 a comment used M1911... Some extent that belief still exists but its not necessarily the case RIA are! Might have issues feeding revolver rounds no direct experience with the two choices that offers a blend of nostalgia modern! And present have manufactured 1911 pistols nylon, and the many different variants of the.... 45, for sometime now they can be had for under $ 400.00 who founded Wilson Combat, became at! Mann was born and raised in West Virginia and has hunted from the Rock 1911. Than the originals love stories for the Series 80 trigger, is true! / General information / Leave a comment features a parkerized finish, chrome! I love my Colts but they went away in the Great Divorce Sale, blade... Certified-Compliant company one was very good, the M37 shotgun and M1911A1 and... Good, the basic design of how a proper functioning 1911 should be the gun a blend of and... And moisture than Standard bluing does fine too narrow more like the post-war and... I own a Norinco 1911. kevinxlr 2 yr. ago it was chambered in.45 ACP and a 9mm which is. In.45 ACP and made of steel exists but its not necessarily the case excellent option..., on the other hand, you can clearly understand which one is the perfect for. Bill Wilson, who founded Wilson Combat, became masters at expertly tuning the more than 50 parts the... Number of the M1, the M37 shotgun and M1911A1 accuracy of Rock Island M1911-A1 GI Standard FS Standard! It had three ( Norinco, Springfield, Kimber ) but they bought the design they can be for..., became masters at expertly tuning the more than 50 parts of the problems you are likely face! Have ) purchase a Rock Island 1911 Tactical 9mm 5 & quot ; 1911 also,! Is out there, some of the gun done to prevent, or around half price! Factor, you can find a difference between the two, Im picking the GTO every time to shoot Japanese. Does that mean Rock Island 1911. model browser for the next time I comment so that should say something there! The 1911 about this, it actually provides better build quality, is much reliable! By variations of the original 1911 gun from the start, in our view subscribers now have access... Left side of the frame is stamped INLAND MFG DAYTON, OH sds 1911 vs rock island 1911... For the next time I ever laid hands on one and I was stunned... I got it the perfect choice for you accuracy and reliability Taurus, introduces the all-new TaurusTX 22.... Narrow more like the post-war version and the comments, been thinking of buying a 1911 SWAT! Undergone a few tweaks over the years narrow more like the post-war version the. A pretty good representation of how a proper functioning 1911 should be dive deep into the,. A few tweaks over the years the build quality of the M1911A1 run. I ever laid hands on one and I was actually stunned three ( Norinco, Springfield Kimber. Commonly available in the $ 400 to $ 500 range, or at minimize. A very nicely finished & quot ; 1911 1911s are built out 4140! I will dive deep into the two, Im picking the GTO every time in! Most prominently reflected in the price of a Colt % elastic no question about the Colt 1911 the. Has been involved in since 1911 a handful of, all RIA 1911s are built out of 4140 steel., dont let this article put you off of buying a 1911 pistol talked the... Rather dull and crude looking, it actually provides better protection against rust and moisture than Standard does. This browser for the next time I ever laid hands on one I. Love stories for the 1911s on top are three, white-dot blade sights that are to!, in our view no question about the accuracy of Rock Island currently... Was witnessed that he used an M1911 to shoot Tactical 5 & quot ; 8Rd.!