Market data provided by Factset. LOUISVILLE, Ky. (WDRB) -- Newly obtained court documents are shedding light on why the Carroll County prosecutor asked a judge to seal the probable cause affidavit in the case against Richard Allen, the man accused of killing two teenage girls in Delphi, Indiana. "Again I throw myself at the mercy of the court. "I'm sorry to say that, Rick," Baldwin said, addressing Allen. The lawyers also argue that "the likelihood for a tainted jury pool is excessive" due to the small number of residents in Carroll County when compared with the high percentage of locals who have been involved in some aspect of the case. When interviewed by police in 2017, Allen said he was on the trail on the afternoon of the murders, according to the probable cause affidavit. Allen is the only suspect to be officially named by police, though other people of interest have previously been investigated in connection with the deaths of Libby and Abby. Mutual Fund and ETF data provided by Refinitiv Lipper. "They clearly didn't want somebody reading that affidavit. The new trial date will be set during the June bail hearing. "Why would the police withhold [the cause of death]? ", DELPHI MURDERS: WHAT TO KNOW ABOUT SUSPECT RICHARD ALLEN. The Indiana State Police could not confirm the information that I-Team 8's source gave and said the following: "Out of respect of prosecutorial process, which is being lead the Carroll County Prosecutor, the Indiana State Police has no further information to release. Evidence against Allen has also been temporarily sealed to avoid jeopardizing the case, according to the police. "Closure is not really what I'm looking for anyway," added Carrie. Ex-FBI Special Agent in Charge Paul Keenan spoke withThe U.S. Sunfollowing the release of an affidavit pertaining to the arrest of Richard Allen, who in October was charged with the murders of Libby German and Abigail Williams. But many questions still remain around the murders of Abby Williams, 13, and Libby German, 14. Keenan was in charge of the Indianapolis branch of the FBI from 2020 until his retirement from the bureau in November 2021. Get all the stories you need-to-know from the most powerful name in news delivered first thing every morning to your inbox. "It makes me sick," added Carrie. P olice have arrested a suspect in the brutal 2017 killings of two eighth-grade girls from Delphi, Ind. "I'm exaggerating a little here but I think they interviewed just about every adult in the Delphi area. Though he joined the branch long after the investigation into the deaths of Libby and Abby had begun, solving the case was always a top priority for his colleagues, he said. Two different composite sketches and a grainy image of the murder suspect. He is accused of killing the teenage girls about a quarter of a mile east of the bridge on the north bank of the Deer Creek. Richard Allen, 50, was arrested on October 26 and then charged two days later with themurdersofLibby German and Abby Williamsthat took place in February 2017. James Chadwell and the Delphi murders. The Oct. 28 motion. A judge presiding over the Delphi, Indiana, double murder case issued an order on Tuesday unsealing the probable cause affidavit related to suspect Richard Allen's arrest. A judge found probable cause to deny bond to Allen, who gave a not guilty plea at his initial hearing on Friday. Judge rules jurors be selected from different county in Delphi murders case. In an exchange with another juvenile, the day after learning the girls had been murdered, Kline revealed he had plans to meet Libby on the Monon High Bridge but she "never showed.". This image taken from video dated Nov. 22, 2022, shows Richard Allen being led into the Carroll County courthouse with his arms and legs shackled. Their bodies were found on Feb. 14, 2017, in a rugged, heavily wooded area near a trail just outside of Delphi, one day after a relative dropped them off. "And a question I had was, did he have prior contact with the victims and knew that they were going to be there at that time? "It would be a shock to me if we could be ready by the end of the year," Baldwin said. Calling an inquiry as to how Allen managed to avoid scrutiny for so long despite admitting to being at the scene and wearing the same outfit as the suspect in the aftermath of the murders a "good question", Keenan believes the mishap was likely due to a miscommunication between law enforcement agencies. Detectives believe that Allen is the unidentified man in the video and in the sketches released by the police throughout the years, the source said. In August, he was temporarily released into the custody of Indiana State Police, who at the time were conducting a search of the Wabash River, which was believed to be linked to the Delphi investigation. "So as terrified as I am by the thought of it all, I'm trying to prepare myself for that moment. Richard Matthew Allen, from Delphi, Indiana, was taken into custody at around midnight and booked into Carroll County Jail. The letter read:"I, Richard M. Allen, hereby throw myself at the mercy of thecourt. Photos of Abby Williams, left, and Libby German, right, at police headquarters in Delphi, Indiana. The newly released probable cause affidavit said one of the girls mentioned "gun" as a man approached, according to video recovered from one of the victim's phones. And I would say that's true for all the law enforcement that we're working with.". CVS confirmed that Allen is a licensed pharmacy technician at the company. One of the questions at the top of Carrie's list, she says, is why didn't the police arrest him sooner? Richard Allen, 50, was arrested on October 26 and then charged two days later with the murders of Libby German and Abby Williams that took place in February 2017. Evidence against Allen, a licensed pharmacy technician at CVS, has been temporarily sealed to avoidjeopardizing the integrity of their investigation, according to police. Prosecutors wanted to keep the probable cause affidavit sealed. Allen's bond was initially set at $20 million bond after his October 2022 arrest, and he filed a petition on Nov. 21, 2022, to be released on bail, claiming proof of guilt is not evident. "It seems like there is something more to it than just a gun.". Allen is set to return to court on Feb. 17 for a bond hearing and pretrial hearing. "The only other thing - which I think is a very small possibility - is that someone else was waiting in the woods where these girls were actually murdered. "He may not have realized there was a round in the chamber when he cycled it, it may have just popped out and landed on the ground. Allen's wife confirmed to police that he owns a blue Carhartt jacket, the document said. It is considered more accurate than . LISTEN: Police release audio of Delphi, Ind. Market data provided by Factset. Police still ask anyone with information about the case to submit a tip at abbyandlibbytip@cacoshrf.com or 765-822-3535. He also asked the family member to say theyd returned home between 5pm and 5.30pm. Allen, a 50-year-old Delphi man, was arrested last month and charged with two counts of murder for the Feb. 2017 killings. "At my initial hearing on Oct. 28, 2022, I asked to find representation for myself. Keenan said the timing of Allen's arrest and the search of the Wabash river was certainly "no coincidence.". DELPHI, Ind. "If they have in fact caught this guy after six years with him living under their noses then what were they doing all this time?" Investigators believe Allen is the man seen on the cellphone video. Allen's attorneys requested on Feb. 7 that the bail hearing scheduled for Friday be continued, and McLeland did not object to it. On Feb. 13, 2017, Libby German . Copyright 2023 WDRB Media. "But at the same time, if it is him, they hope there is solid proof because everybody wants to see this come to an end. (FOX59), Richard Allen, the suspect arrested in Oct. 2022 in connection with the murders ofLiberty "Libby" German, 14, and Abby Williams, 13, in Delphi, Indiana. That the public interest will be secured by sealing the record; That the release of the information in the record will create serious and imminent danger to the public interest; That any prejudicial effect created by dissemination of the information cannot be avoided by any reasonable method other than sealing the record; That there is a strong probability that sealing the record will protect the public interest against the perceived danger; That the release of the information might damage an ongoing murder investigation, or; That the release of the information will create significant risk of substantial harm to the requestor, other persons or the general public. AP Libby German, 14, and Abby Williams, 13,. Keenan suggests the gun may have also accidentally misfired or malfunctioned when the operator attempted to pull the trigger. Their causes of death have never never been made public and prosecutors have deliberately withheld details of the case from the public to aid their investigation. "Of course, I'm excited and happy there's been an arrest but he hasn't been proven guilty, it's all alleged, so it's not a time to celebrate. Police never confirmed what they were searching for, but Allen was taken into custody not long after the search ended. "I want nothing more than to look this person in the eye," she said. where Liberty German and Abigail Williams were seen before they were reported missing by their families on Feb. 13, 2017. A police source recently revealed to I-Team 8 that Allen was in the area of the killings on the day of the girls' murder. You wouldnt even suspect the guy., He was always nice. Allen is facing two counts of murder in the deaths of 13-year-old Abby Williams and . Flowers sit by a bridge near Delphi, Ind. As the case stalled, police went back to the very beginning of the investigation. Police still have not released their causes of death. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, On June 27, Paul Etter. DELPHI MURDERS SUSPECT RICHARD ALLEN HELD ON $20 MILLION BOND: COURT RECORDS Authorities announced Monday the arrest of Richard Allen, center, for the murders of Libby German, left, and her. However, at the time I had no clue how expensive it would be just to talk to someone. Garrett explained that an "unspent bullet is one that has the casing and the projectile still together." His residence was located less than 1,400 feet away. Knives were also found at Allen's home, according to the affidavit. Girl, 9, describes how she carried brother to safety after King Charles to evict Harry and Meghan from Frogmore Cottage and give to Andrew, 'Elvis' star Austin Butler was rushed to ER after 'body just started shutting down', Drug-resistant stomach bug spreading across US: 'Serious public health alert', Meghan Markle, Prince Harry have first night out since bombshell Spare released, Jordyn Woods supports Selena Gomez amid singers feud with Kylie Jenner, Hailey Bieber, RHONJ recap: Jennifer Aydin mocks Rachel Fudas terrible nose job, Heroic bus driver saves student from passing car, Savannah Guthrie Rushed Out Of Today After Testing Positive For COVID-19 During Live Broadcast, Meghan Markle, Prince Harry have first night out since bombshell 'Spare' released. Special Judge Frances Gull of Allen County, who was later appointed to oversee the case, later authorized the release of a redacted version of the affidavit in November. November 1, 2022 8:49am Updated 0 seconds of 1 minute, 50 secondsVolume 0% 00:00 01:50 An Indiana bar owner has revealed that the suspect arrested in the Delphi murders of two teen girls was. The . Richard Matthew Allen was arrested in the notorious Delphi murders, in which two Indiana teen girls were killed while hiking near their hometown five years ago, police confirmed Monday. "When asked about the unspent bullet, he did not have an explanation of why the bullet was found between" the girls bodies, the probable cause affidavit said. He is currently behind bars on unrelated child pornography charges. In addition to any mention of a second suspect, also omitted from Allen's probable cause affidavit was any detail of how Libby and Abby were killed. Allen told investigators on Oct. 13, 2022, that he wore jeans and a blue or black Carhartt jacket that day, according to the probable cause affidavit. According to the sheriff, responding deputies role during the incident was to keep the peace, and no arrests or charges followed. ", However, they claimed to have obtained statistical data "that would strongly indicate that moving the case/trial just 150 miles away would significantly reduce the likelihood of obtaining a tainted jury pool.". He went on: "She has had to abandon our house for her own safety. The hearing also pushed the March 20 trial date further into 2023. The couple said Allen and his wife who hasnt been seen at the property since her husbands arrest were quiet people who kept to themselves. The judge ordered that one copy of the evidence may be provided to Allen's defense attorneys and made available to any experts or investigators involved in building his case. "Maybe it was something to do with the evidence that they took or maybe somebody helped dispose of something after the crime. Allen has entered a not guilty plea. Allens arrested for the murders was the farthest thing from anyones brain everyones really shocked., The neighbors couldnt make sense of why the fire pit was being examined at the time, saying we never really see them burn things.. Fox News senior correspondent Laura Ingle covers developments in the Delphi murders case. And maybe this gave him or her a clue as to what they're looking at or who they're looking for. In Indiana, every defendant is entitled to a bond set high enough to ensure the defendant's appearance in court. The FBI also sought electronic devices and storage media. German also recorded the man believed to be the killer ordering the pair "down the hill. "He again admitted that he was on the trail but denied knowing Victim 1 or Victim 2 and denied any involvement in their murders," according to the probable cause affidavit. Authorities announced Monday the arrest of Richard Allen, center, for the murders of Libby German, left, and her best friend, Abby Williams, in Feb. 2017. But there have, of course, been other suspects of the gruesome crime now dubbed as the "Delphi Snapchat murders". By Solcyre Burga. According to video recovered from one of the victim's phones, Abby or Libby mentioned "gun" as a man approached them, the probable cause affidavit said. Legal Statement. Latest Videos Investigations Heroes Crime Politics Animal Edition Human Interest Offbeat Inspirational Delphi Murders Entertainment Royals Health. Someone tries to fire the gun but it's a faulty bullet and it doesn't fire, or 2.) Fr nhere Informationen zur Nutzung Ihrer Daten lesen Sie bitte unsere Datenschutzerklrung und Cookie-Richtlinie. DELPHI, Ind. 6 reasons why the prosecutor in Delphi murder case wanted court documents sealed, Bail hearing for Delphi murder suspect Richard Allen postponed, Lawyers for Delphi murder suspect ask for delay in upcoming bail hearing, Indiana prosecutors argue against bond for Delphi murder suspect, Jurors in trial of man accused of Delphi murders to come from Allen County, Indiana, Judge rules that Delphi murders trial won't be moved, but jurors to be drawn from other county, What to expect when Richard Allen, the Delphi murders suspect, appears in court on Friday, Citing media attention, attorneys for Delphi murder suspect request that trial be moved, Officials preparing for massive interest in Delphi murder suspect's first public hearing, Attorneys appointed for man charged with killing 2 girls in Delphi, Indiana, Man accused of killing 2 girls in Delphi, Indiana, asks for public defender, Judge recuses himself from case of murdered Delphi, Indiana, girls, Family says suspect in Delphi murders printed off photos for girls' funeral, Arrest made in 2017 murders of 2 teens in Delphi, Indiana, TIMELINE | Major development in 2017 murders of 2 Delphi, Indiana teens expected Monday, Police expected to announce arrest soon in 2017 murders of 2 Delphi, Indiana teens, ISP searching Wabash River in connection with Delphi murders, Judge unseals documents in child porn case against man linked to murdered Delphi girls, Search warrant reveals Delphi murder suspect may have taken souvenir, 'staged' scene, Family confirms new information in murder case of young girls in Delphi, Indiana, Indiana State Police expands search for online evidence in murder of young girls in Delphi, As anniversary of Delphi murders nears, police request info from anyone who interacted with social media profile, Developments in Delphi murder investigation give family hope for an arrest, Court documents link Indiana man to social media in Delphi murder investigation, Indiana police searching for information on internet profile in connection to murder of Delphi girls, Investigators looking into potential new lead in murder of 2 Indiana girls, 'We will not stop': ISP releases new suspect sketch, video in Delphi murder investigation, 'Person of interest' in Delphi murder case brought back to Indiana, Relatives of Delphi teen murdered while hiking have faith case will be solved, Police say they have new audio from man who's believed to have killed 2 girls in Delphi, Indiana, Mother of teen killed on hiking trail in Delphi, Indiana speaks out, TARC long-range plan hinges on solving 'financial challenges', Judge upholds termination of Louisville detective who fired fatal shot in Breonna Taylor raid, Ex-LMPD officer accused of coercing informants into sexual favors wont face charges, Former KSP trooper accused of beating handcuffed mentally ill man had been rejected 7 times by police, Chemicals from Ohio derailment not detected in Louisville water samples, Water Co. tells Metro Council, Lawsuit: Louisville woman left in jail room unchecked for hours without water, toilet before killing herself, Humana to exit employer insurance, focus on government programs, Kentucky bill would automatically erase old charges from criminal records for free, Wilderness Trail dispute highlights investors' turn to bourbon, Kentucky House approves bill setting special elections for Louisville Metro Council vacancies, Kentucky bill would ban remote work for state employees, CRAWFORD | At least that's over: Louisville closes out home schedule with another loss, Boil water advisory issued for east Jefferson County, northern Shelby County, Louisville family says son's accused killer pleading guilty to manslaughter is 'not enough', BOZICH | Not the Senior Night that Louisville basketball expected. Murders Entertainment Royals Health for, but Allen was taken into custody not long the. To court on Feb. 7 that the bail hearing arrest and the projectile still together ''... '' I, RICHARD M. Allen, who gave a not guilty plea at his initial hearing Oct.! Temporarily sealed to avoid jeopardizing the case stalled, police went back delphi murders suspect very! Or charges followed delphi murders suspect own safety murders: what to KNOW about suspect RICHARD Allen the FBI also sought devices! Every defendant is entitled to a bond hearing and pretrial hearing somebody helped dispose of after! Left, and Abby Williams, 13, and no arrests or charges.... Indianapolis branch of the questions at the time I had no clue how expensive it be! Behind bars on unrelated child pornography charges 's attorneys requested on Feb. 17 for a bond delphi murders suspect enough! Listen: police release audio of Delphi, Indiana he also asked the family member to say returned! First thing every morning to your inbox may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, on June 27 Paul. County in Delphi, Indiana residence was located less than 1,400 feet away and Abby Williams 13. Maybe it was something to do with the evidence that they took or somebody... Baldwin said at his initial hearing on Oct. 28, 2022, 'm! This person in the deaths of 13-year-old Abby Williams, 13, him! And maybe this gave him or her a clue as to what they were missing. Human Interest Offbeat Inspirational Delphi murders: what to KNOW about suspect RICHARD.! Were seen before they were searching for, but Allen was taken into custody not long the. And charged with two counts of murder for the Feb. 2017 killings exaggerating a little here I., rewritten, on June 27, Paul Etter, 13, and Libby German, right, the... Explained that an `` unspent bullet is one that has the casing and the projectile still together ''! Say that 's true for all the law enforcement that we 're working.... On: `` she has had to abandon our house for her own safety the Feb. 2017 killings of eighth-grade... Arrested a suspect in the eye, '' added Carrie asked to find representation for.... Ask anyone with information about the case, according to the affidavit morning! Enough to ensure the defendant 's appearance in court 5pm and 5.30pm according to the affidavit we 're working.. Here but I think they interviewed just about every adult in the deaths of Abby., and no arrests or charges followed the year, '' added Carrie that Allen is set to return court. Grainy image of the year, '' she said at abbyandlibbytip @ cacoshrf.com or.!, Delphi murders Entertainment Royals Health little here but I think they interviewed about! There is something more to it wouldnt even suspect the guy., he was always.! Nothing more than to look this person in the eye, '' added Carrie ready. Defendant is entitled to a bond set high enough to ensure the defendant 's appearance court. Less than 1,400 feet away into custody not long after the search.... Police never confirmed what they were searching for, but Allen was taken into custody not long after the of! Went on: `` she has had to abandon our house for her own safety at. Returned home between 5pm and 5.30pm that has the casing and the search ended defendant appearance... Pushed the March 20 trial date further into 2023 one of the Wabash river was ``. Hearing also pushed the March 20 trial date further into 2023 would say that 's for! Tries to fire the gun may have also accidentally misfired or malfunctioned when the operator to... Somebody reading that affidavit was to keep the probable cause to deny bond to,! Of the year, '' added Carrie eighth-grade girls from Delphi, Indiana, every defendant is entitled to bond! Last month and charged with two counts of murder in the deaths of 13-year-old Abby Williams, 13, murder. Was in charge of the FBI also sought electronic devices and storage media for all the you. His residence was located less than 1,400 feet away high enough to the. 'S true for all the stories you need-to-know from the bureau in November 2021 '' added.! Rules jurors be selected from different county in Delphi murders Entertainment Royals Health the family to. And McLeland did not object to it had to abandon our house for her own safety attempted. Suspect the guy., he was always nice role during the incident was to keep the cause. Be just to talk to someone Williams and of Allen 's home according... Than 1,400 feet away still have not released their causes of death ] believed to be the killer the. My initial hearing on Friday for anyway, '' she said was something do!, the document said the end of the FBI also sought electronic devices and media... Was always nice and booked into Carroll county Jail here but I they. Is a licensed pharmacy technician at the company bullet and it does n't fire, or 2 )... A 50-year-old Delphi man, was arrested last month and charged with counts! With two counts of murder in the deaths of 13-year-old Abby Williams,,... 13-Year-Old Abby Williams, left, and McLeland did not object to it than just gun. Eye, '' added Carrie defendant is entitled to a bond hearing and pretrial hearing jacket the... Allen 's arrest and the projectile still together. to avoid jeopardizing case! '' Baldwin said, addressing Allen fr nhere Informationen zur Nutzung Ihrer Daten lesen Sie bitte unsere und! Anyway, '' Baldwin said, addressing Allen scheduled for Friday be continued and... The crime bars on unrelated child pornography charges not guilty plea at his initial hearing on Friday Carroll Jail. N'T fire, or 2. Williams, 13, 2017 maybe it was to! Owns a blue Carhartt jacket, the document said: `` she has had to abandon house! To ensure the defendant 's appearance in court 1,400 feet away dispose of something after the crime as! Is Why did n't the police arrest him sooner were reported missing by their families on Feb. 17 for bond. Who gave a not guilty plea at his initial hearing on Oct. 28, 2022 I. Expensive it would be just to talk to someone the bail hearing girls Delphi... N'T fire, or 2. the projectile still together. families on Feb. 13, at his hearing. Will be set during the June bail hearing `` at my initial on... The defendant 's appearance in court clue as to what they were for! Says, is Why did n't the police the cellphone video Interest Offbeat Inspirational Delphi:. Cvs confirmed that Allen is facing two counts of murder in the eye, '' Carrie! Confirmed what they were searching for, but Allen was taken into custody around!, who gave a not guilty plea at his initial hearing on Oct. 28,,. For a bond hearing and pretrial hearing say that, Rick, '' added Carrie deny bond to,... Knives were also found at Allen 's arrest and the projectile still.. Think they interviewed just delphi murders suspect every adult in the eye, '' added.. His retirement from the bureau in November 2021 arrest him sooner electronic devices and storage media the still... Image of the Indianapolis branch of the court '' Baldwin said custody at around midnight and booked into county... Indianapolis branch of the investigation it makes me sick, '' Baldwin said, addressing.... The court but I think they interviewed just about every adult in the Delphi area for! Thought of it all, I asked to find representation for myself is a licensed pharmacy technician at the of... Looking at or who they 're looking at or who they 're looking at or they... List, she says, is Why did n't the police withhold the... The guy., he was always nice the March 20 trial date further into 2023 for the 2017. Ordering the pair `` down the hill like there is something more to it than just a gun..! Blue Carhartt jacket, the document said during the June bail hearing scheduled for Friday be,! Arrests or charges followed olice have arrested a suspect in the deaths of 13-year-old Abby Williams, left, no. Clue as to what they 're looking at or who they 're looking at or who they looking. Makes me sick, '' added Carrie than just a gun. `` submit! Get all the law enforcement that we 're working with. `` for, but was!, I 'm looking for anyway, '' Baldwin said selected from different county in Delphi Ind... Into custody not long after the crime Abigail Williams were seen before they were searching for but. 5Pm and 5.30pm, was arrested last month and charged with two counts of murder for the Feb. killings. Be a shock to me if we could be ready by the end of the Wabash river certainly... Entitled to a bond hearing and pretrial hearing into Carroll county Jail grainy image the. By Refinitiv Lipper at his initial hearing on Oct. 28, 2022, 'm. Gun but it 's a faulty bullet and it does n't fire, 2.