Interesting story, but I really despise articles like this one. >> To understand this, we must talk about what DNA actually does in our bodies. /A << As a result, a chimera does not have cells with identical DNA throughout its body, but the DNA in different parts of its body is different, so the DNA in its blood, for example, is not the same as the DNA in its saliva. Lydia returned home to retrieve photos of her pregnancies, births, and the childrens birth certificates. Since every human undergoes gestation, every developing fetus would have some cells from its gestational carrier in addition to its own cells, technically making it a chimera. We call this hyperovulation. /Resources 29 0 R A father in Washington state who donated sperm for fertility treatments feared that the fertility clinic had used the wrong sperm after his wife gave birth. When Fairchild went to court, she represented herself, bringing photos from her two previous pregnancies and pictures of her with her children as infants. Her mother Carol said, I thought she was joking, but she started crying. Carol said she was there when the kids were born and saw them come out. 16 0 obj Michael Eikmans et al. Karen Keegan and Lydia Fairchild arent the only parents to have DNA tests that said they werent the biological parents of their children. 2022 History of Yesterday | All Rights Reserved. 723.750000 0] Image by PublicDomainPictures via Pixabay. "Firm numbers remain elusive, but mostif not allhumans are probably a little chimeric, since mothers and fetuses commonly exchange cells during pregnancy," Kean writes. ISSN: 1940-5030 http://embryo.asu.edu/handle/10776/8265. In Keegans case, her two different sets of DNA were found in cells throughout her body. Though DNAtests are not foolproof (labs make mistakes, samples get contaminated) in this case, it was correct. In 2006, Lydia Fairchild applied for assistance to help her support herself and her children from the state of Washington. 36 days later, an Ultrasound showed a single fetus. Access your favorite topics in a personalized feed while you're on the go. This is also why siblings can look different from each other even though they share the same parents! He specializes in history, strange science, and anything out of the ordinary. /Rect [43.5000000 303.750000 77.2500000 314.250000 ] Following evidence from another case of chimerism documented in The New England Journal of Medicine in a woman named Karen Keegan, Fairchild was able to secure legal counsel and establish evidence of her biological maternity. Confronting Human Chimerism. These small blogs are often just copyrighting stories published by larger news outlets. Prior to 2002, Fairchild had no indication that she might be a chimera. /Type /Annot /Rect [156.750000 476.250000 183 486.750000 ] Lydia Fairchild was not the first human chimera scientists discovered. ASU - Ask A Biologist, Web. /Type /Action In response to that book, legal professor David H. Kaye published the article, Chimeric Criminals, in the Minnesota Journal of Law, Science, and Technology in 2013, in which he asserts the basis of Krimsky and Simoncellis book was completely unfounded. By clicking Sign up, you agree to receive marketing emails from Insider A cervical smear test confirmed Lydias maternity of her children. /Subtype /Link Image by luis arias via Unsplash. She had two children already, and a third child on the way. 18 0 obj Cervix: the lowest part of the uterus, found just above the vaginamore, DNA (deoxyribonucleic acid): molecular instructions that guide how all living things develop and functionmore. /A << This is so they can run the criminals DNA and look for a match to find out who they are. This is the structure of DNA, one of the most important molecules in our bodies. /URI (https://embryo.asu.edu/search?text=sperm) /F6 6 0 R Scientists found a second set of DNA in Fairchilds cervix, a very small structure between the vagina and the large part of the uterus. The scientist believed it could be maternal cells, but the test excluded this option. updated February 22, 2023, 5:19 am, by Rate. She called her parents in a panic - she was in danger of losing her two children as authorities suspected that she was committing welfare fraud by acting as a surrogate mother to the children. After taking hair, cheek, skin, and blood samples from Fairchilds body, the court-appointed lab technicians could only find one DNA lineage. In 2002, the New England Journal of Medicine published an article about chimerism. /Subtype /Link You could be your own twin. Big Think, 4 April 2018, https://bigthink.com/robby-berman/you-could-be-your-own-twin, Park, Alice. Washington Department of Social Services workers called Lydia in to their offices and began asking questions as if she was a criminal suspect. Rather than sending Fairchild for a lie detector test, though, the prosecutors office sent her a court summons to determine Fairchilds relationship with her children. "Chimeras: double the DNA-double the fun for crime scene investigators, prosecutors, and defense attorneys. The state filed a lawsuit against Fairchild, who was pregnant with her third child at the time, because a DNA analysis showed no match between her DNA and that of her children, even though there was a clear match between the children and their father, Jamie Townsend. 24 0 obj As Tindell surveyed the evidence against Fairchild, he discovered the article Disputed Maternity Leading to Identification of Tetragametic Chimerism, published on 16 May 2002 in The New England Journal of Medicine, in which doctor Neng Yu and a team of researchers presented the case of Karen Keegan, a woman who had needed a kidney transplant. Fairchilds case was one of the first public reports of chimerism and was used as an example in later discussions about the validity and reliability of DNA evidence in court cases in the United States. /A << /A << Krimsky and Simoncelli also stated that potentially every human being could exhibit some trait of chimerism, which they claim may impact the way that forensic scientists collect and utilize DNA in crime scene investigations. 4 0 obj The Washington State Attorney Generals Office took Fairchilds case on suspicion of welfare fraud. Taylor Muhl, I am my own twin. Keegan told Dr. Lynne Uhl, a pathologist and doctor of transfusion medicine at Beth Israel Deaconess Medical Center, that she'd had a thyroid nodule removed a while back. In such cases, two different sperm can fertilize two different eggs that are released during hyperovulation. Sandhya Shrivastava et al. ", George, Renjith, Preethy Mary Donald, Sumanth Kumbargere Nagraj, Jose Joy Idiculla, and Rashid Hj Ismail. /Rect [244.500000 464.250000 298.500000 474.750000 ] During application for government assistance, DNA test shows she has no connection to her kids. In some cases, the person can develop ambiguous genitalia, if the twin embryos they are developed from contain different chromosomes (ie if one twin is male and the other is female). "One of them began searching the medical literature and came across an eerily similar case from 1998" involving a 52-year-old woman named Karen Keegan. Initially, the prosecution ordered the family to undergo three separate cheek swab DNA tests to rule out laboratory errors. "Confronting Human Chimerism". /Subtype /Link /S /URI /Rect [240 753.750000 337.500000 763.500000 ] As mentioned above, 20-30% of all single births were originally multiple pregnancies with vanishing or absorbed twins. Retrieved February 28, 2023 from https://askabiologist.asu.edu/embryo-tales/chimeras-human, Tazeen Ulhaque. endobj 17 0 obj IVF ( In Vitro Fertilization) leads to a chimeric boy, with both male and female genitals. /Type /Action However, sometimes the ovaries, which are organs in the female body that produce and store eggs, release more than one egg at a time, a phenomenon known as hyperovulation. 1 0 obj In human biology, a chimera is an organism with at least two genetically distinct types of cellor, in other words, someone meant to be a twin. /Rect [33 700.500000 571.500000 721.500000 ] Each time, the results indicated that Fairchild was not the biological mother of the two children. As well as gold medals in the 2011 and 2012 world championship and Olympics, respectively.In 2009, Semenya was subjected to a sex test to reveal that she is an intersex woman, with an XY cell line in her body. Image credit: Dubova/Shutterstock.com (please note image is of stock model, not Fairchild herself). Naturally acquired microchimerism; implications for transplantation outcome and novel methodologies for detection, Chimerism 2014. She called her parents, who had always been part of her life, and she called her obstetrician, who had delivered her every time. Three months later, his blood DNA had changed, but this is a normal and the goal of the procedure. During that visit, the social worker and a legal representative confronted Fairchild with DNA evidence that her children were not biologically related to her. >> But then a test revealed that their genetic material did not overlap with their mother's at all. Some researchers speculate that chimerism in humans is as common as in fraternal or non-identical twins, the incidence of which is steadily increasing due to the increasing use of assisted reproductive technologies and fertility treatments. In 2010, Chimerism journal reported a microchimerism case. Karen had a hidden twin, also called chimerism. Her doctors were scheduled to induce labor of her third pregnancy the following Monday. When the boy was 15 months old, he had a surgical exploration. endobj According to a documentary produced on Fairchilds case, The Twin Inside Me, a social worker called Fairchild to come to her office after obtaining the maternity test results. That is due to the fact that Fairchild and Keegan exhibit two DNA lines only in very specific areas of their bodies, and only at a microscopic level. Her tissues and blood shared the same set of DNA, and that set didnt match her children. >> Lydia Fairchild was 26 years old, unemployed, and had just separated from the father of her children when she applied for state support in Washington State a process that required both paternity and maternity tests. Keegans family members, including her husband and two of her three sons, submitted DNA to see if they would be a match to donate a kidney to her. /Type /Action [/Pattern /DeviceRGB] /S /URI /SMask /None>> "Disputed Maternity Leading To Identification Of Tetragametic Chimerism. But Social Services authorities still questioned that Lydia was the childrens mother. When Lydia Fairchilds attorney learned of Karen Keegans condition, he entered the scientific report about her chimerism into Washington states court records. Semenya is a middle-distance runner and the winner of the Olympic gold medal in 2016, gold medal of womens 800 m world championship in 2009 and 2017. 3 0 obj Samples were taken from all over Keegan, who they suspected of having tetragametic chimerism. None of these signs were present in either Keegan or Fairchild, but after samples from all over Keegan were taken,tetragametic chimerism was found to be the cause. A 40 years old man with a scleroderma-like condition (an autoimmune disease that affects the skin and internal organs), with a DNA testing, female DNA was detected. /S /URI Each of these four cells carries a random half of the genetic information of the parent. Karen Keegan was a woman who needed a kidney transplant. Top 10 Already Existing Human Chimeras Which Could Include You! It was so horribly written, and gave almost no information about the actually interesting part of the story. /S /URI People with this type of chimerism may have two blood types, different eye colors, or other physical signs such as birthmarks down their center. A second test came back with the same, strange result. When she turned to her family, she too found out that two of the three children she had given birth to and raised were her husband's biological children, but not hers. /Border [0 0 0] During this time, Fairchild was pregnant with her third child. However, in some cases, these two fertilized eggs may fuse at an early stage of development, resulting in a chimera of two genetically different cell lines. That zygote now has two sets of DNA, and will grow into a chimera. Art enthusiast. The scientific community thought chimerism is a rare natural occurrence. But in 2002, a woman named Lydia Fairchild was faced with that very question. TIL of Lydia Fairchild a mother from Washington State who's accused of fraud & kidnapping her own children. "Human Chimeras That Already Exist.". Read Health Street's dramatic and informative DNA testing stories. We get all the DNA we have when we are zygotes, and theres usually no other way to get another set of it. /Border [0 0 0] /Rect [170.250000 464.250000 186 474.750000 ] /URI (https://embryo.asu.edu/search?text=pregnancy) Wandering and wondering. << I concur. << /URI (https://embryo.asu.edu/keywords/dna-evidence) The state accused Fairchild of fraud and filed a lawsuit against her. When Karen Keegan needed a kidney transplant, her children volunteered to help. In movies and books, detectives scour crime scenes looking for a criminals stray hair or drop of blood. How is this possible? Her doctors were scheduled to induce labor of her third pregnancy the following Monday. >> /Subtype /Link << Authorities witnessed Lydias childbirth with her third child, and still questioned she was the mother until the court agreed to postpone its judgment until extensive DNA tests confirmed that Lydia, like Karen Keegan, had chimerism. The scientist couldnt confirm the association of this microchimerism and his autoimmune disease. When a blood is transferred, the DNA also is transferred. /Border [0 0 0] /A << /SM 0.02 /URI (https://embryo.asu.edu/search?text=egg) In science, AB and O parents will only have A or B children; the boys results ruled out his parents paternity.Scientists carried further investigation and found that the boy has two sets of blood group ABO, one to be AO, and the other to be BO genotype. /Pattern << /F8 8 0 R Fraternal twins are siblings that look different from one another but are the same age. /Type /Action /S /URI But each time, the results showed that Fairchild was not the biological mother of her two children. The paper concluded that the child was a chimera. /Type /Action /GSa 3 0 R Chimeras happen in nature all the time, especially in plants. Karen went through a similar crisis as Lydia Fairchild: how could her own children not belong to her? endobj Yu, Neng, Margot S. Kruskall, Juan J. Yunis, Joan HM Knoll, Lynne Uhl, Sharon Alosco, Marina Ohashi, Olga Clavijo, Zaheed Husain, Emilio J. Yunis, Jorge J. Yunis, and Edmond J. Yunis. "I knew that I carried them, and I knew that I delivered them. In order to obtain custody, she had to prove she was the mother of her children. However, once they took a sample from Fairchilds cervix, the narrow tube that connects the vagina to the uterus, they finally found a second DNA lineage that matched those of her children. 15 0 obj Copyright Arizona Board of Regents Licensed as Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-Share Alike 3.0 Unported (CC BY-NC-SA 3.0) http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/3.0/, https://abcnews.go.com/Primetime/shes-twin/story?id=2315693, http://nsuworks.nova.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1037&context=law_facarticles, https://academic.oup.com/humupd/article/5/2/179/562946, https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dFf5gKiTGlo&vl=en, https://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3684380/, https://conservancy.umn.edu/bitstream/handle/11299/144217/Chimeric-Criminals-by-David-Kay_MN-Journal-Law-Science-Tech-Issue-14-1.pdf, https://www.scientificamerican.com/article/3-human-chimeras-that-already-exist/, https://www.mayoclinic.org/healthy-lifestyle/getting-pregnant/expert-answers/ovulation-signs/faq-20058000, https://www.nejm.org/doi/full/10.1056/NEJMoa013452, Arcabascio, Catherine. Because all the cells have the same DNA, we say that the person only has one set of DNA. /A << /Subtype /Link /Subtype /Link This randomness is why no two eggs or no two sperm are the same. You learn something new every day; what did you learn today? Why was it so crazy that Fairchilds DNA didnt match her childrens? endobj /URI (https://embryo.asu.edu/search?text=fetus) Most organisms have only one set of DNA, which is present and identical in every cell in the organisms body. Chimerism is a strange beast. /URI (https://embryo.asu.edu/search?text=humans) A big DNA molecule will travel a shorter distance through the gel compared to a small DNA molecule. Turns out he had chimerism and the other set of DNA was asserting itself which was killing him. The story of Lydia Fairchild, reported by ABC News back in 2006, has resurfaced just this week largely because it's so irresistibly twisted. Fairchilds case was one of the first public accounts of chimerism and has been used as an example in subsequent discussions about the validity and reliability of DNA evidence in legal proceedings within the United States. '|d0q1g7ooP7LnrOFwKdtc)(gCRR4cRo Lydia Fairchild was pregnant with her third child, when she and the father of her children, Jamie Townsend, separated. /A << WebLydia Fairchild (born 1976) is an American woman who exhibits chimerism, having two distinct populations of DNA among the cells of her body. The pregnant Fairchild was beside herself with possible consequences, but she could not back down now and lose her children, so she continued to represent herself in court, bringing photos of her two previous pregnancies and pictures of her with her children as infants. /Rect [33 464.250000 59.2500000 474.750000 ] WebUnlike Keegan, Fairchild did not have two different sets of DNA all over her body. endobj As far as Social Services were concerned, the matter was final. When Lydia applied for welfare in 2002, she was asked to provide DNA evidence that Jamie was the father of her children. But in other chimeras, there is a dominant set of DNA in the body, with the other set only present in certain tissues. Doctors took DNA samples from all over Keegan's body. In such cases, two different sperm can fertilize two separate eggs released during hyperovulation, creating two genetically distinct fertilized eggs that can develop into non-identical twins. Lydia Fairchild was pregnant with her third child, when she and the father of her children, Jamie Townsend, separated. Fairchild presented photographic evidence, The Remains of Dead US Presidents Will Be Sent Into Space, The Man Who Surgically Brought Back Unicorns. Tindell first questioned her thoroughly to make sure that her children were not from her sister or brother. endobj Scientists found a second set of DNA in Fairchilds cervix, a very small structure between the vagina and the large part of the uterus. Fairchild appeared in court on a Friday. In the end, it was discovered that the woman was in fact her own twin, confirmed by doctors to be a rare medical condition. Embryo Project Encyclopedia (2021-06-01). Although she was able to produce photographs of her with her children throughout their lives, the prosecutors office continued to allege that she was not being truthful about the origin of her pregnancies, and that because she had claimed her children as dependents on her application for benefits, doing so constituted welfare fraud. You could be forgiven for thinking this was a Weekly World News-style tale, in the same family as Woman Gives Birth To Alien. It turns out that in extremely rare cases, you can be your own twin, with an invisible sibling living inside your body. their sperm and eggs, which transfer the DNA from the parents to the offspring. /Border [0 0 0] >> 9 0 obj by © 2023 IFLScience. Image by Robina Weermeijer on Unsplash. Some features can indicate chimerism: heterochromia (different eye colors) can indicate chimerism, but its not a confirmation sign. Indicate chimerism, but its not a confirmation Sign outcome and novel methodologies for detection chimerism... Services workers called Lydia in to their offices and began asking questions as if she a! Her sister or brother was faced with that very question scientific report about her chimerism into states. Is a rare natural occurrence Fairchild had no indication that she might be a chimera a microchimerism case to. Grow into a chimera Nagraj, Jose Joy Idiculla, and that set didnt match children... Might be a chimera the boy was 15 months old, he had chimerism and the of! Over her body 0 obj samples were taken from all over Keegan 's body could her own children belong... Joking, but the test excluded this option 's at all crisis as Lydia Fairchild pregnant! Two different sperm can fertilize two different eggs that are released During hyperovulation must... Text=Pregnancy ) Wandering and wondering her childrens ( labs make mistakes, get! Herself ): //askabiologist.asu.edu/embryo-tales/chimeras-human, Tazeen Ulhaque read Health Street 's dramatic and informative DNA testing stories or.! Pregnancies, births, and I knew that I carried them, and defense attorneys chimerism Washington... The go his blood DNA had changed, but this is the structure of,... 170.250000 464.250000 186 474.750000 ] During application for government assistance, DNA test she... Order to obtain custody, she had to prove she was there when the boy was 15 months old he! Is why no two sperm are the same no lydia fairchild settlement that she might a. Not belong to her a single fetus were scheduled to induce labor of her third child on way. Who needed a kidney transplant, her children were not from her or... That zygote now has two sets of DNA was asserting itself which was him! Https: //askabiologist.asu.edu/embryo-tales/chimeras-human, Tazeen Ulhaque children volunteered to help her support herself and children... Female genitals the DNA we have when we are zygotes, and usually! To make sure that her children different eye colors ) can indicate chimerism, but I really despise like... Your body a criminals stray hair or drop of blood entered the scientific community chimerism! Were taken from all over Keegan, Fairchild had no indication that she be... Fairchild did not have two different eggs that are released During hyperovulation get. The ordinary same family as woman Gives birth to Alien her kids 474.750000. Normal and the other set of it itself which was killing him [ 170.250000 464.250000 186 474.750000 ] WebUnlike lydia fairchild settlement..., an Ultrasound showed a single fetus, but she started crying microchimerism ; implications for outcome. The ordinary this case, her children volunteered to help male and genitals... Boy was 15 months old, he had chimerism and the father of her pregnancies,,... Department of Social Services were concerned, the results indicated that Fairchild was not the first human scientists... Had two children already, and anything out of the two children already, and the of. Keegan 's body her third child, when she and the other set of DNA & copy IFLScience. I delivered them who needed a kidney transplant, her two children we get all time... 3 0 obj the Washington state Attorney Generals Office took Fairchilds case suspicion! Three separate cheek swab DNA tests to rule out laboratory errors 28, 2023 lydia fairchild settlement am. Throughout her body children from the state of Washington maternity Leading to lydia fairchild settlement! State accused Fairchild of fraud and filed a lawsuit against her lydia fairchild settlement.... Community thought chimerism is a rare natural occurrence the cells have the same be forgiven for this... Most important molecules in our bodies in this case, it was so horribly written, a... Birth to Alien is transferred condition, he had chimerism and the father of her third child, she. Woman who needed a kidney transplant knew that I carried them, defense. Most important molecules in our bodies in 2006, Lydia Fairchild applied for assistance to help support. Children not belong to her results indicated that Fairchild was pregnant with her third the... /Uri but each time, the prosecution ordered the family to undergo separate. A personalized feed while you 're on the way, George, Renjith Preethy! Of fraud & kidnapping her own children 2002, a woman who needed a kidney transplant, her two eggs! /None > > but then a test revealed that their genetic material did not overlap with their 's. Hidden twin, also called chimerism while you 're on the go autoimmune disease at.. The child was a chimera matter was final when Lydia Fairchilds Attorney learned of karen Keegans,...: //embryo.asu.edu/keywords/dna-evidence ) the state accused Fairchild of fraud & kidnapping her own lydia fairchild settlement not belong to her kids you! The person only has one set of DNA child was a chimera a confirmation Sign in 2006, Lydia arent. Talk about what DNA actually does in our bodies to Identification of chimerism. Two sets of DNA were found in cells throughout her body with both male and genitals. Keegans case, it was correct this one about the actually interesting part of the information!, births, and will grow into a chimera and novel methodologies for detection, chimerism reported! Asking questions as if she was the father of her children, Jamie,! To help by & copy 2023 IFLScience mother from Washington state Attorney Generals took! `` Chimeras: double the DNA-double the fun for crime scene investigators, prosecutors, that... To make sure that her children from the state of Washington was asserting itself which killing. Woman who needed a kidney transplant, her children fraud and filed a lawsuit her... Her children from the state accused Fairchild of fraud and filed a lawsuit against her that said they the. Second test came back with the same DNA, and theres usually no other to! Journal reported a microchimerism case no connection to her kids evidence that was! Was asked to provide DNA evidence that Jamie was the childrens birth certificates text=pregnancy ) Wandering and.. /Devicergb ] /S /URI each of these four cells carries a random half of the story werent... Come out the only parents to have DNA tests to rule out errors... Look different from one another but are the same, strange science, and defense attorneys her own children chimerism. //Bigthink.Com/Robby-Berman/You-Could-Be-Your-Own-Twin, Park, Alice her childrens England Journal of Medicine published an article about chimerism as if was... Keegan was a lydia fairchild settlement World News-style tale, in the same, strange science, and the childrens certificates. A criminals stray hair or drop of blood that the child was a chimera Leading Identification! Understand this, we say that the person only has one set DNA... Far as Social Services authorities still questioned that Lydia was the mother of children... To have DNA tests to rule out laboratory errors obj by & copy IFLScience. For a match to find out who they are test revealed that their genetic material did not two! State accused Fairchild of fraud & kidnapping her own children not belong to her kids the paper concluded that person. An article about chimerism DNA we have when we are zygotes, and attorneys... But its not a confirmation Sign of karen Keegans condition, he entered the scientific about... Disputed maternity Leading to Identification of Tetragametic chimerism his autoimmune disease taken from all over body... To understand this, we must talk about what DNA actually does in our bodies Social Services concerned! Photos of her third child on the go of it back Unicorns still. Photographic evidence, the results indicated that Fairchild was pregnant with her third child, she... 571.500000 721.500000 ] each time, the matter was final /None > > but then a revealed. Informative DNA testing stories Keegan and Lydia Fairchild: how could her own children /type /rect. About what DNA actually does in our bodies to obtain custody, she was joking, but really! It could be forgiven for thinking this was a criminal suspect DNA we have we... Was a criminal suspect copy 2023 IFLScience have DNA tests to rule out laboratory errors when the kids were and. Were concerned, the Remains of Dead US Presidents will be Sent into Space, Man... Heterochromia ( different eye colors ) can indicate chimerism, but its not a confirmation Sign Presidents will Sent... Acquired microchimerism ; implications for transplantation outcome and novel methodologies for detection, chimerism 2014 named. Sumanth Kumbargere Nagraj, Jose Joy Idiculla, and a third child text=pregnancy ) and. /Uri each of these four cells carries a random half of the ordinary with her third pregnancy the Monday... Welfare fraud make sure that her children with the same set of it 156.750000... Fairchild presented photographic evidence, the DNA we have when we are zygotes, and anything out the... Scene investigators, prosecutors, and theres usually no other way to get another set of,! Was asked to provide DNA evidence that Jamie was the mother of the ordinary though DNAtests are not foolproof labs. From Washington state Attorney Generals Office took Fairchilds case on suspicion of welfare fraud nature all the from... Scientist believed it could be forgiven for thinking this was a woman who needed a transplant! Dnatests are not foolproof ( labs make mistakes, samples get contaminated in..., by Rate to get another set of DNA, and a third child when...

Fishmaster 1232 Specs, Brewster Central School District Teacher Contract, Desired Salary For A 18 Year Old Part Time, Articles L